C-411 Second Reading Recorded Vote

This bill went to a recorded vote at Second Reading on December 12th, 2007. It was defeated by a margin of 184-68. Results of the vote are below.

Name Party Voted Comment
Abbott, Jim (Hon) - Kootenay-Columbia Conservative Nay
Ablonczy, Diane (Hon) - Calgary-Nose Hill Conservative Nay
Albrecht, Harold - Kitchener-Conestoga Conservative Nay
Alghabra, Omar - Mississauga-Erindale Liberal Nay
Allen, Mike - Tobique-Mactacquac Conservative Nay
Allison, Dean - Niagara West-Glanbrook Conservative Nay
Ambrose, Rona (Hon) - Edmonton-Spruce Grove Conservative Nay
Anders, Rob - Calgary West Conservative Nay
Anderson, David - Cypress Hills-Grasslands Conservative Nay
Andre, Guy - Berthier-Maskinonge Bloc Quebecois Yea
Angus, Charlie - Timmins-James Bay NDP Yea
Arthur, Andre - Portneuf-Jacques-Cartier Independent Nay
Asselin-Gerard - Manicouagan Bloc Quebecois Yea
Atamanenko, Alex - British Columbia Southern Interior NDP Yea
Bachand, Claude - St-Jean Bloc Quebecois Yea
Bagnell, Larry (Hon) - Yukon Liberal Nay
Bains, Navdeep (Hon) - Mississauga-Brampton South Liberal Nay
Baird, John (Hon) - Ottawa West-Nepean Conservative
Barbot, Vivian - Papineau Bloc Quebecois Yea
Barnes, Sue - London West Liberal Nay
Batters, Dave - Palliser Conservative Nay
Beaumier, Colleen - Brampton West Liberal Nay
Belanger, Mauril (Hon) - Ottawa Vanier Liberal Nay
Bell, Catherine - Vancouver Island North NDP Yea
Bell, Don H. - North Vancouver Liberal Nay
Bellavance, Andre - Richmond-Arthabaska Bloc Quebecois Yea
Bennett, Carolyn (Hon) - St. Paul's Liberal Nay
Benoit, Leon - Vegreville-Wainwright Conservative Nay
Bernier, Maxime (Hon) - Beauce Conservative
Bevilacqua, Maurizio (Hon) - Vaughan Liberal Nay
Bevington, Dennis - Western Arctic NDP Yea
Bezan, James - Selkirk-Interlake Conservative Nay
Bigras, Bernard - Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie Bloc Quebecois
Black, Dawn - New Westminster-Coquitlam NDP
Blackburn, Jean-Pierre (Hon) - Jonquiere-Alma Conservative Nay
Blaikie, Bill (Hon) - Elmwood-Transcona NDP Yea
Blais, Raynald - Gaspesie-Iles-de-la-Madeleine Bloc Quebecois Yea
Blaney, Steven - Levis-Bellechasse Conservative Nay
Bonin, Raymond - Nickel Belt Liberal Nay
Bonsant, France - Compton-Stanstead Bloc Quebecois Yea
Boshcoff, Ken - Thunder Bay-Rainy River Liberal
Bouchard, Robert - Chicoutimi-Le Fjord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Boucher, Sylvie - Beauport-Limoilou Conservative Nay
Bourgeois, Diane - Terrebonne-Blainville Bloc Quebecois Yea
Breitkreuz, Gary - Yorkton-Melville Conservative Nay
Brison, Scott (Hon) - Kings-Hants Liberal Nay
Brown, Bonnie - Oakville Liberal Nay
Brown, Gord - Leeds-Grenville Conservative Nay
Brown, Patrick - Barrie Conservative Nay
Bruinooge, Rod - Winnipeg South Conservative Nay
Brunelle, Paule - Trois-Rivieres Bloc Quebecois
Byrne, Gerry (Hon) - Humber-St. Barbe-Baie Verte Liberal
Calkins, Blaine - Wetaskiwin Conservative Nay
Cannan, Ron - Kelowna-Lake Country Conservative Nay
Cannis, John - Scarborough Centre Liberal Nay
Cannon, Lawrence (Hon) - Pontiac Conservative Nay
Cardin, Serge - Sherbrooke Bloc Quebecois Yea
Carrie, Colin - Oshawa Conservative Nay
Carrier, Robert - Alfred-Pellan Bloc Quebecois Yea
Casey, Bill - Cumberland-Colchester-Musquodoboit Valley Independent Nay
Casson, Rick - Lethbridge Conservative Nay
Chamberlain, Brenda (Hon) - Guelph Liberal
Chan, Raymond (Hon) - Richmond Liberal Nay
Charlton, Chris - Hamilton Mountain NDP Yea
Chong, Michael (Hon) - Wellington-Halton Hills Conservative Nay
Chow, Olivia - Trinity-Spadina NDP Yea
Christopherson, David - Hamilton Centre NDP Yea
Clement, Tony (Hon) - Parry Sound-Muskoka Conservative Nay
Coderre, Denis (Hon) - Bourassa Liberal
Comartin, Joe - Windsor-Techumseh NDP
Comuzzi, Joe (Hon) - Thunder Bay-Superior North Conservative Nay
Cotler, Irwin (Hon) - Mount Royal Liberal
Crete, Paul - Montmagny-L'Islet-Karmouraska-Riviere-du-Loup Bloc Quebecois Yea
Crowder, Jean - Nanaimo-Cowichan NDP Yea
Cullen, Nathan - Skeena-Bulkley Valley NDP
Cullen, Roy (Hon) - Etobicoke North Liberal Nay
Cummins, John - Delta-Richmond East Conservative Nay
Cuzner, Rodger - Cape Breton-Canso Liberal Nay
D'Amours, Jean-Claude - Madawaska-Restigouche Liberal
Davidson, Patricia - Sarnia-Lambton Conservative Nay
Davies, Libby - Vancouver East NDP Yea
Day, Stockwell (Hon) - Okanagan-Coquihalla Conservative Nay
DeBellefeuille, Claude - Beauharnois-Salaberry Bloc Quebecois
Del Mastro, Dean - Peterborough Conservative Nay
Demers, Nicole - Laval Bloc Quebecois Yea
Deschamps, Johanne - Laurentides-Labelle Bloc Quebecois Yea
Devolin, Barry - Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock Conservative Nay
Dewar, Paul - Ottawa Centre NDP Yea
Dhaliwal, Sukh - Newton-North Delta Liberal Nay
Dhalla, Ruby - Brampton-Springdale Liberal Nay
Dion, Stephane (Hon) - St. Laurent-Cartierville Liberal
Dosanjh, Ujjal (Hon) - Vancouver South Liberal
Doyle, Norman - St. John's East Conservative Nay
Dryden, Ken (Hon) - York Centre Liberal Nay
Duceppe, Gilles - Laurier-Sainte-Marie Bloc Quebecois Yea
Dykstra, Rick - St. Catharines Conservative Nay
Easter, Wayne (Hon) - Malpeque Liberal Nay
Emerson, David (Hon) - Vancouver Kingsway Conservative Nay
Epp, Ken - Edmonton-Sherwood Park Conservative Nay
Eyking, Mark (Hon) - Sydney-Victoria Liberal Nay
Faille, Meili - Vaudreuil-Soulanges Bloc Quebecois
Fast, Ed - Abbotsford Conservative Nay
Finley, Diane (Hon) - Haldimand-Norfolk Conservative Nay
Fitzpatrick, Brian - Prince Albert Conservative Nay
Flaherty, Jim (Hon) - Whitby-Oshawa Conservative
Fletcher, Steven - Charleswood-St. James-Assiniboia Conservative Nay
Folco, Raymonde - Laval-Les Iles Liberal
Freeman, Carole - Chateauguay-Saint-Constant Bloc Quebecois Yea
Fry, Hedy (Hon) - Vancouver Centre Liberal
Gagnon, Christiane - Quebec Bloc Quebecois Yea
Galipeau, Royal - Ottawa-Orleans Conservative Nay
Gallant, Cheryl - Renfrew-Nipissing-Pembroke Conservative Nay
Gaudet, Roger - Moncalm Bloc Quebecois Yea
Godfrey, John (Hon) - Don Valley West Liberal Nay
Godin, Yvon - Acadie-Bathurst NDP Yea
Goldring, Peter - Edmonton East Conservative Nay
Goodale, Ralph (Hon) - Wascana Liberal Nay
Goodyear, Gary - Cambridge Conservative Nay
Gourde, Jacques - Lotbiniere-Chutes-de-la-Chaudiere Conservative Nay
Gravel, Raymond - Repentigny Bloc Quebecois Yea
Grewal, Nina - Fleetwood-Port Kells Conservative Nay
Guarnieri, Albina (Hon) - Mississauga East-Cooksville Liberal
Guay, Monique - Riviere-du-Nord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Guergis, Helena (Hon) - Simcoe-Grey Conservative Nay
Guimond, Michel - Montmorency-Charlevoix-Haute-Cote-Nord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Hanger, Art - Calgary Northeast Conservative Nay
Harper, Stephen (Rt Hon) - Calgary Southwest Conservative
Harris, Richard - Cariboo-Prince George Conservative Nay
Harvey, Luc - Louis-Hebert Conservative Nay
Hawn, Laurie - Edmonton Centre Conservative Nay
Hearn, Loyola (Hon) - St. John's South-Mount Pearl Conservative Nay
Hiebert, Russ - South Surrey-Whiterock-Cloverdale Conservative Nay
Hill, Jay (Hon) - Prince George-Peace River Conservative Nay
Hinton, Betty - Kamloops-Thompson-Cariboo Conservative
Holland, Mark - Ajax-Pickering Liberal Nay
Hubbard, Charles (Hon) - Miramichi Liberal Nay
Ignatieff, Michael - Etobicoke-Lakeshore Liberal Nay
Jaffer, Rahim - Edmonton-Strathcona Conservative Nay
Jean, Brian - Fort McMurray-Athabasca Conservative Nay
Jennings, Marlene (Hon) - Notre Dame de Grace-Lachine Liberal
Julian, Peter - Burnaby-New Westminster NDP
Kadis, Susan - Thornhill Liberal Nay
Kamp, Randy - Pitt Meadows-Maple Ridge-Mission Conservative Nay
Karetak-Lindell, Nancy - Nunavut Liberal Nay
Karygiannis, Jim (Hon) - Scarborough-Agincourt Liberal Nay
Keddy, Gerald - South Shore-St. Margaret's Conservative Nay
Keeper, Tina - Churchill Liberal
Kenney, Jason (Hon) - Calgary Southeast Conservative Nay
Khan, Wajid - Mississauga-Streetsville Conservative
Komarnicki, Ed - Souris-Moose Mountain Conservative Nay
Kotto, Maka - Saint-Lambert Bloc Quebecois Yea
Kramp, Daryl - Prince Edward-Hastings Conservative Nay
Laforest, Jean-Yves - Saint-Maurice-Champlain Bloc Quebecois Yea
Laframboise, Mario - Argenteuil-Papineau-Mirabel Bloc Quebecois Yea
Lake, Mike - Edmonton-Millwoods-Beaumont Conservative Nay
Lalonde, Francine - La Pointe-de-L'Ile Bloc Quebecois
Lauzon, Guy - Stormont-Dundas-South Glengarry Conservative Nay
Lavallee, Carole - Saint-Bruno-Saint-Hubert Bloc Quebecois Yea
Layton, Jack (Hon) - Toronto-Danforth NDP Yea
Lebel, Denis - Roberval-Lac-Saint-Jean Conservative Nay
LeBlanc, Dominic (Hon) - Beausejour Liberal
Lee, Derek - Scarborough-Rouge River Liberal Nay
Lemay, Marc - Abitibi-Temiscaminque Bloc Quebecois
Lemieux, Pierre - Glengarry-Prescott-Russell Conservative Nay
Lessard, Yves - Chambly-Borduas Bloc Quebecois Yea
Levesque, Yvon - Abitibi-Baie-James-Nunavik-Eeyou Bloc Quebecois Yea
Lukiwski, Tom - Regina-Lumsden-Lake Centre Conservative Nay
Lunn, Gary (Hon) - Saanich-Gulf Islands Conservative Nay
Lunney, James - Nanaimo-Alberni Conservative Nay
Lussier, Marcel - Brossard-La Prairie Bloc Quebecois Yea
MacAuley, Lawrence (Hon) - Cardigan Liberal
MacKay, Peter (Hon) - Central Nova Conservative
MacKenzie, Dave - Oxford Conservative Nay
Malhi, Gurbax (Hon) - Bramalea-Gore-Malton Liberal Nay
Malo, Luc - Vercheres-Les Patriotes Bloc Quebecois Yea
Maloney, John - Welland Liberal Nay
Manning, Fabian - Avalon Conservative Nay
Mark, Inky - Dauphin-Swan River-Marquette Conservative
Marleau, Diane (Hon) - Sudbury Liberal
Marston, Wayne - Hamilton East-Stoney Creek NDP Yea
Martin, Keith (Hon) - Esquimault-Juan de Fuca Liberal Nay
Martin, Pat - Winnipeg Centre NDP Yea
Martin, Paul (Hon) - LaSalle-Emard Liberal
Martin, Tony - Sault Ste. Marie NDP
Masse, Brian - Windsor West NDP
Mathyssen, Irene - London-Fanshawe NDP Yea
Matthews, Bill - Random-Burin-St. George's Liberal Nay
Mayes, Colin - Okanagan-Shuswap Conservative Nay
McCallum, John (Hon) - Markham-Unionville Liberal
McDonough, Alexa - Halifax NDP Yea
McGuinty, David - Ottawa South Liberal Nay
McGuire, Joe (Hon) - Egmont Liberal Nay
McKay, John (Hon) - Scarborough-Guildwood Liberal Nay
McTeague, Dan (Hon) - Pickering-Scarborough East Liberal Nay
Menard, Real - Hochelaga Bloc Quebecois Yea
Menard, Serge - Marc-Aurele-Fortin Bloc Quebecois Yea
Menzies, Ted - Macleod Conservative Nay
Merrifield, Rob - Yellowhead Conservative Nay
Miller, Larry - Bruce-Grey-Owen Sound Conservative Nay
Milliken, Peter (Hon) - Kingston and the Islands Liberal Speaker only votes in a tie
Mills, Bob - Red Deer Conservative Nay
Minna, Maria (Hon) - Beaches-East York Liberal Nay
Moore, James - Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam Conservative Nay
Moore, Rob - Fundy-Royal Conservative Nay
Mourani, Maria - Ahuntsic Bloc Quebecois
Mulcair, Thomas - Outremont NDP Yea
Murphy, Brian - Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe Liberal
Murphy, Shawn (Hon) - Charlottetown Liberal Nay
Nadeau, Richard - Gatineau Bloc Quebecois Yea
Nash, Peggy - Parkdale-High Park NDP Yea
Neville, Anita (Hon) - Winnipeg South Centre Liberal Nay
Nicholson, Rob (Hon) - Niagara Falls Conservative Nay
Norlock, Rick - Northumberland-Quinte West Conservative Nay
Obhrai, Deepak - Calgary East Conservative Nay
O'Connor, Gordon (Hon) - Carleton-Mississippi Mills Conservative Nay
Oda, Bev (Hon) - Durham Conservative Nay
Ouellet, Christian - Brome-Missisquoi Bloc Quebecois Yea
Pacetti, Massimo - Saint-Leonard-Saint-Michel Liberal Nay
Pallister, Brian - Portage-Lisgar Conservative Nay
Paquette, Pierre - Joliette Bloc Quebecois Yea
Paradis, Christian (Hon) - Megantic-L'Erable Conservative Nay
Patry, Bernard - Pierrefonds-Dollard Liberal Nay
Pearson, Glen - London North Centre Liberal Nay
Perron, Gilles-A. - Riviere-des-Mille-Iles Bloc Quebecois Yea
Petit, Daniel - Charlesbourg-Haute-Saint-Charles Conservative Nay
Picard, Pauline - Drummond Bloc Quebecois Yea
Plamandon, Louis - Bas-Richelieu-Nicolet-Becancour Bloc Quebecois Yea
Poilievre, Pierre - Nepean-Carleton Conservative Nay
Prentice, Jim (Hon) - Calgary Centre-North Conservative Nay
Preston, Joe - Elgin-Middlesex-London Conservative Nay
Priddy, Penny - Surrey North NDP Yea
Proulx, Marcel - Hull-Aylmer Liberal
Rajotte, James - Edmonton-Leduc Conservative Nay
Ratansi, Yasmin - Don Valley East Liberal Nay
Redman, Karen (Hon) - Kitchener Centre Liberal
Regan, Geoff (Hon) - Halifax West Liberal Nay
Reid, Scott - Lanark-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington Conservative Nay
Richardson, Lee - Calgary Centre Conservative Nay
Ritz, Gerry (Hon) - Battlefords-Lloydminster Conservative Nay
Robillard, Lucienne - Westmount-Ville-Marie Liberal
Rodriguez, Pablo - Honore-Mercier Liberal
Rota, Anthony - Nipissing-Timiskaming Liberal
Roy, Jean-Yves - Haute-Gaspesie-La Mitis-Matane-Matapedia Bloc Quebecois Yea
Russell, Todd - Labrador Liberal Nay
Savage, Michael - Dartmouth-Cole Harbour Liberal Nay
Savoie, Denise - Victoria NDP Yea
Scarpaleggia, Francis - Lac-Saint-Louis Liberal Nay
Scheer, Andrew - Regina-Qu'Appelle Conservative
Schellenberger, Gary - Perth-Wellington Conservative Nay
Scott, Andy (Hon) - Fredericton Liberal Nay
Sgro, Judy (Hon) - York West Liberal
Shipley, Bev - London-Kent-Middlesex Conservative Nay
Siksay, Bill - Burnaby-Douglas NDP Yea
Silva, Mario - Davenport Liberal
Simard, Raymond (Hon) - St. Boniface Liberal Nay
Simms, Scott - Bonavista-Gander-Grand Falls-Windsor Liberal Nay
Skelton, Carol (Hon) - Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar Conservative Nay
Smith, Joy - Kildonan-St. Paul Conservative Nay
Solberg, Monte (Hon) - Medicine Hat Conservative Nay
Sorenson, Kevin - Crowfoot Conservative Nay
St. Amand, Lloyd - Brant Liberal Nay
St. Denis, Brent - Algoma-Manitoulin-Kapuskasing Liberal Nay
Stanton, Bruce - Simcoe North Conservative Nay
St. Cyr, Thierry - Jeanne-Le Ber Bloc Quebecois Yea
Steckle, Paul - Huron Bruce Liberal Nay
St-Hilaire, Caroline - Longueuil-Pierre-Boucher Bloc Quebecois Yea
Stoffer, Peter - Sackville-Eastern Shore NDP Yea
Storseth, Brian - Westlock-St. Paul Conservative Nay
Strahl, Chuck (Hon) - Chilliwack-Fraser Canyon Conservative Nay
Stronach, Belinda (Hon) - Newmarket-Aurora Liberal
Sweet, David - Ancaster-Dundas-Flamborough-Westdale Conservative Nay
Szabo, Paul - Mississauga South Liberal Nay
Telegdi, Andrew (Hon) - Kitchener-Waterloo Liberal Nay
Temelkovski, Lui - Oak Ridges-Markham Liberal Nay
Thi Lac, Eve-Mary Thai - Saint-Hyancinthe-Bagot Bloc Quebecois Yea
Thibault, Louise - Rimouski-Neigette-Temiscouata-Les Basques Independent Yea
Thibault, Robert - West Nova Liberal Nay
Thompson, Greg Francis (Hon) - New Brunswick Southwest Conservative Nay
Thompson, Myron - Wild Rose Conservative Nay
Tilson, David - Dufferin-Caledon Conservative Nay
Toews, Vic (Hon) - Provencher Conservative Nay
Tonks, Alan - York South-Weston Liberal Nay
Trost, Bradley - Saskatoon-Humboldt Conservative Nay
Turner, Garth (Hon) - Halton Liberal
Tweed, Mervin - Brandon-Souris Conservative Nay
Valley, Roger - Kenora Liberal Nay
Van Kesteren, Dave - Chatham-Kent-Essex Conservative Nay
Van Loan, Peter (Hon) - York-Simcoe Conservative Nay
Vellacott, Maurice - Saskatoon-Wanuskewin Conservative Nay
Verner, Josee (Hon) - Louis-Saint-Laurent Conservative Nay
Vincent, Robert - Shefford Bloc Quebecois Yea
Volpe, Joseph (Hon) - Elgin-Lawrence Liberal
Wallace, Mike - Burlington Conservative Nay
Wappel, Tom - Scarborough Southwest Liberal Nay
Warawa, Mark - Langley Conservative Nay
Warkentin, Chris - Peace River Conservative Nay
Wasylycia-Leis, Judy - Winnipeg North NDP Yea
Watson, Jeff - Essex Conservative Nay
Wilfert, Bryon (Hon) - Richmond Hill Liberal Nay
Williams, John - Edmonton-St. Albert Conservative Nay
Wilson, Blair - West Vancouver-Sunshine Coast-Sea to Sky Country Independent
Wrzesnewskyi, Borys - Etobicoke Centre Liberal Nay
Yelich, Lynne - Blackstrap Conservative Nay
Zed, Paul - St. John Liberal
Unless stated otherwise Content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License