C-394 Second Reading Recorded Vote

This bill went to a recorded vote at Second Reading on March 5th, 2008. It was defeated by a margin of 177-99 (with four members being paired). Results of the vote are below.

Name Party Voted Comment
Abbott, Jim (Hon) - Kootenay-Columbia Conservative Nay
Ablonczy, Diane (Hon) - Calgary-Nose Hill Conservative Nay
Albrecht, Harold - Kitchener-Conestoga Conservative Nay
Alghabra, Omar - Mississauga-Erindale Liberal Nay
Allen, Mike - Tobique-Mactacquac Conservative Nay
Allison, Dean - Niagara West-Glanbrook Conservative Nay
Ambrose, Rona (Hon) - Edmonton-Spruce Grove Conservative Nay
Anders, Rob - Calgary West Conservative Nay
Anderson, David - Cypress Hills-Grasslands Conservative Nay
Andre, Guy - Berthier-Maskinonge Bloc Quebecois Yea
Angus, Charlie - Timmins-James Bay NDP
Arthur, Andre - Portneuf-Jacques-Cartier Independent Nay
Asselin-Gerard - Manicouagan Bloc Quebecois Yea
Atamanenko, Alex - British Columbia Southern Interior NDP Yea
Bachand, Claude - St-Jean Bloc Quebecois Yea
Bagnell, Larry (Hon) - Yukon Liberal Nay
Bains, Navdeep (Hon) - Mississauga-Brampton South Liberal Nay
Baird, John (Hon) - Ottawa West-Nepean Conservative Nay
Barbot, Vivian - Papineau Bloc Quebecois Yea
Barnes, Sue - London West Liberal Nay
Batters, Dave - Palliser Conservative Nay
Beaumier, Colleen - Brampton West Liberal
Belanger, Mauril (Hon) - Ottawa Vanier Liberal Nay
Bell, Catherine - Vancouver Island North NDP Yea
Bell, Don H. - North Vancouver Liberal Yea
Bellavance, Andre - Richmond-Arthabaska Bloc Quebecois Yea
Bennett, Carolyn (Hon) - St. Paul's Liberal Nay
Benoit, Leon - Vegreville-Wainwright Conservative Nay
Bernier, Maxime (Hon) - Beauce Conservative
Bevilacqua, Maurizio (Hon) - Vaughan Liberal Nay
Bevington, Dennis - Western Arctic NDP Yea
Bezan, James - Selkirk-Interlake Conservative Nay
Bigras, Bernard - Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie Bloc Quebecois Yea
Black, Dawn - New Westminster-Coquitlam NDP Yea
Blackburn, Jean-Pierre (Hon) - Jonquiere-Alma Conservative Nay
Blaikie, Bill (Hon) - Elmwood-Transcona NDP
Blais, Raynald - Gaspesie-Iles-de-la-Madeleine Bloc Quebecois Yea
Blaney, Steven - Levis-Bellechasse Conservative Nay
Bonin, Raymond - Nickel Belt Liberal Nay
Bonsant, France - Compton-Stanstead Bloc Quebecois Yea
Boshcoff, Ken - Thunder Bay-Rainy River Liberal
Bouchard, Robert - Chicoutimi-Le Fjord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Boucher, Sylvie - Beauport-Limoilou Conservative Nay
Bourgeois, Diane - Terrebonne-Blainville Bloc Quebecois Yea
Breitkreuz, Gary - Yorkton-Melville Conservative Nay
Brison, Scott (Hon) - Kings-Hants Liberal Nay
Brown, Bonnie - Oakville Liberal Yea
Brown, Gord - Leeds-Grenville Conservative Nay
Brown, Patrick - Barrie Conservative Nay
Bruinooge, Rod - Winnipeg South Conservative Nay
Brunelle, Paule - Trois-Rivieres Bloc Quebecois Yea
Byrne, Gerry (Hon) - Humber-St. Barbe-Baie Verte Liberal
Calkins, Blaine - Wetaskiwin Conservative Nay
Cannan, Ron - Kelowna-Lake Country Conservative Nay
Cannis, John - Scarborough Centre Liberal Yea
Cannon, Lawrence (Hon) - Pontiac Conservative Nay
Cardin, Serge - Sherbrooke Bloc Quebecois Yea
Carrie, Colin - Oshawa Conservative Nay
Carrier, Robert - Alfred-Pellan Bloc Quebecois Yea
Casey, Bill - Cumberland-Colchester-Musquodoboit Valley Independent
Casson, Rick - Lethbridge Conservative Nay
Chamberlain, Brenda (Hon) - Guelph Liberal
Chan, Raymond (Hon) - Richmond Liberal Nay
Charlton, Chris - Hamilton Mountain NDP Yea
Chong, Michael (Hon) - Wellington-Halton Hills Conservative Nay
Chow, Olivia - Trinity-Spadina NDP Yea
Christopherson, David - Hamilton Centre NDP Yea
Clement, Tony (Hon) - Parry Sound-Muskoka Conservative Nay
Coderre, Denis (Hon) - Bourassa Liberal
Comartin, Joe - Windsor-Techumseh NDP Yea
Comuzzi, Joe (Hon) - Thunder Bay-Superior North Conservative Nay
Cotler, Irwin (Hon) - Mount Royal Liberal Nay
Crete, Paul - Montmagny-L'Islet-Karmouraska-Riviere-du-Loup Bloc Quebecois Yea
Crowder, Jean - Nanaimo-Cowichan NDP
Cullen, Nathan - Skeena-Bulkley Valley NDP Yea
Cullen, Roy (Hon) - Etobicoke North Liberal Nay
Cummins, John - Delta-Richmond East Conservative Nay
Cuzner, Rodger - Cape Breton-Canso Liberal Nay
D'Amours, Jean-Claude - Madawaska-Restigouche Liberal Nay
Davidson, Patricia - Sarnia-Lambton Conservative Nay
Davies, Libby - Vancouver East NDP Yea
Day, Stockwell (Hon) - Okanagan-Coquihalla Conservative Nay
DeBellefeuille, Claude - Beauharnois-Salaberry Bloc Quebecois Yea
Del Mastro, Dean - Peterborough Conservative Nay
Demers, Nicole - Laval Bloc Quebecois Yea
Deschamps, Johanne - Laurentides-Labelle Bloc Quebecois Yea
Devolin, Barry - Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock Conservative Nay
Dewar, Paul - Ottawa Centre NDP Yea
Dhaliwal, Sukh - Newton-North Delta Liberal Yea
Dhalla, Ruby - Brampton-Springdale Liberal Yea
Dion, Stephane (Hon) - St. Laurent-Cartierville Liberal
Dosanjh, Ujjal (Hon) - Vancouver South Liberal
Doyle, Norman - St. John's East Conservative Nay
Dryden, Ken (Hon) - York Centre Liberal Nay
Duceppe, Gilles - Laurier-Sainte-Marie Bloc Quebecois Yea
Dykstra, Rick - St. Catharines Conservative Nay
Easter, Wayne (Hon) - Malpeque Liberal Nay
Emerson, David (Hon) - Vancouver Kingsway Conservative Nay
Epp, Ken - Edmonton-Sherwood Park Conservative Nay
Eyking, Mark (Hon) - Sydney-Victoria Liberal
Faille, Meili - Vaudreuil-Soulanges Bloc Quebecois Yea
Fast, Ed - Abbotsford Conservative
Finley, Diane (Hon) - Haldimand-Norfolk Conservative Nay
Fitzpatrick, Brian - Prince Albert Conservative Nay
Flaherty, Jim (Hon) - Whitby-Oshawa Conservative
Fletcher, Steven - Charleswood-St. James-Assiniboia Conservative Nay
Folco, Raymonde - Laval-Les Iles Liberal Nay
Freeman, Carole - Chateauguay-Saint-Constant Bloc Quebecois Yea
Fry, Hedy (Hon) - Vancouver Centre Liberal Nay
Gagnon, Christiane - Quebec Bloc Quebecois Yea
Galipeau, Royal - Ottawa-Orleans Conservative Nay
Gallant, Cheryl - Renfrew-Nipissing-Pembroke Conservative Nay
Gaudet, Roger - Moncalm Bloc Quebecois paired
Godfrey, John (Hon) - Don Valley West Liberal Nay
Godin, Yvon - Acadie-Bathurst NDP Yea
Goldring, Peter - Edmonton East Conservative Nay
Goodale, Ralph (Hon) - Wascana Liberal Nay
Goodyear, Gary - Cambridge Conservative Nay
Gourde, Jacques - Lotbiniere-Chutes-de-la-Chaudiere Conservative Nay
Gravel, Raymond - Repentigny Bloc Quebecois Yea
Grewal, Nina - Fleetwood-Port Kells Conservative Nay
Guarnieri, Albina (Hon) - Mississauga East-Cooksville Liberal Nay
Guay, Monique - Riviere-du-Nord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Guergis, Helena (Hon) - Simcoe-Grey Conservative Nay
Guimond, Michel - Montmorency-Charlevoix-Haute-Cote-Nord Bloc Quebecois Yea
Hanger, Art - Calgary Northeast Conservative Nay
Harper, Stephen (Rt Hon) - Calgary Southwest Conservative Nay
Harris, Richard - Cariboo-Prince George Conservative Nay
Harvey, Luc - Louis-Hebert Conservative Nay
Hawn, Laurie - Edmonton Centre Conservative Nay
Hearn, Loyola (Hon) - St. John's South-Mount Pearl Conservative Nay
Hiebert, Russ - South Surrey-Whiterock-Cloverdale Conservative Nay
Hill, Jay (Hon) - Prince George-Peace River Conservative Nay
Hinton, Betty - Kamloops-Thompson-Cariboo Conservative Nay
Holland, Mark - Ajax-Pickering Liberal Yea
Hubbard, Charles (Hon) - Miramichi Liberal Nay
Ignatieff, Michael - Etobicoke-Lakeshore Liberal Nay
Jaffer, Rahim - Edmonton-Strathcona Conservative Nay
Jean, Brian - Fort McMurray-Athabasca Conservative Nay
Jennings, Marlene (Hon) - Notre Dame de Grace-Lachine Liberal Nay
Julian, Peter - Burnaby-New Westminster NDP
Kadis, Susan - Thornhill Liberal Nay
Kamp, Randy - Pitt Meadows-Maple Ridge-Mission Conservative Nay
Karetak-Lindell, Nancy - Nunavut Liberal
Karygiannis, Jim (Hon) - Scarborough-Agincourt Liberal Nay
Keddy, Gerald - South Shore-St. Margaret's Conservative Nay
Keeper, Tina - Churchill Liberal Yea
Kenney, Jason (Hon) - Calgary Southeast Conservative Nay
Khan, Wajid - Mississauga-Streetsville Conservative Nay
Komarnicki, Ed - Souris-Moose Mountain Conservative Nay
Kotto, Maka - Saint-Lambert Bloc Quebecois Yea
Kramp, Daryl - Prince Edward-Hastings Conservative Nay
Laforest, Jean-Yves - Saint-Maurice-Champlain Bloc Quebecois Yea
Laframboise, Mario - Argenteuil-Papineau-Mirabel Bloc Quebecois Yea
Lake, Mike - Edmonton-Millwoods-Beaumont Conservative Nay
Lalonde, Francine - La Pointe-de-L'Ile Bloc Quebecois paired
Lauzon, Guy - Stormont-Dundas-South Glengarry Conservative Nay
Lavallee, Carole - Saint-Bruno-Saint-Hubert Bloc Quebecois Yea
Layton, Jack (Hon) - Toronto-Danforth NDP Yea
Lebel, Denis - Roberval-Lac-Saint-Jean Conservative Nay
LeBlanc, Dominic (Hon) - Beausejour Liberal Nay
Lee, Derek - Scarborough-Rouge River Liberal Nay
Lemay, Marc - Abitibi-Temiscaminque Bloc Quebecois Yea
Lemieux, Pierre - Glengarry-Prescott-Russell Conservative Nay
Lessard, Yves - Chambly-Borduas Bloc Quebecois Yea
Levesque, Yvon - Abitibi-Baie-James-Nunavik-Eeyou Bloc Quebecois Yea
Lukiwski, Tom - Regina-Lumsden-Lake Centre Conservative Nay
Lunn, Gary (Hon) - Saanich-Gulf Islands Conservative Nay
Lunney, James - Nanaimo-Alberni Conservative Nay
Lussier, Marcel - Brossard-La Prairie Bloc Quebecois Yea
MacAuley, Lawrence (Hon) - Cardigan Liberal Nay
MacKay, Peter (Hon) - Central Nova Conservative Nay
MacKenzie, Dave - Oxford Conservative Nay
Malhi, Gurbax (Hon) - Bramalea-Gore-Malton Liberal Yea
Malo, Luc - Vercheres-Les Patriotes Bloc Quebecois Yea
Maloney, John - Welland Liberal Nay
Manning, Fabian - Avalon Conservative Nay
Mark, Inky - Dauphin-Swan River-Marquette Conservative Nay
Marleau, Diane (Hon) - Sudbury Liberal Yea
Marston, Wayne - Hamilton East-Stoney Creek NDP Yea
Martin, Keith (Hon) - Esquimault-Juan de Fuca Liberal Nay
Martin, Pat - Winnipeg Centre NDP Yea
Martin, Paul (Hon) - LaSalle-Emard Liberal
Martin, Tony - Sault Ste. Marie NDP Yea
Masse, Brian - Windsor West NDP Yea
Mathyssen, Irene - London-Fanshawe NDP Yea
Matthews, Bill - Random-Burin-St. George's Liberal
Mayes, Colin - Okanagan-Shuswap Conservative Nay
McCallum, John (Hon) - Markham-Unionville Liberal Nay
McDonough, Alexa - Halifax NDP Yea
McGuinty, David - Ottawa South Liberal Nay
McGuire, Joe (Hon) - Egmont Liberal Nay
McKay, John (Hon) - Scarborough-Guildwood Liberal Nay
McTeague, Dan (Hon) - Pickering-Scarborough East Liberal
Menard, Real - Hochelaga Bloc Quebecois Yea
Menard, Serge - Marc-Aurele-Fortin Bloc Quebecois Yea
Menzies, Ted - Macleod Conservative Nay
Merrifield, Rob - Yellowhead Conservative Nay
Miller, Larry - Bruce-Grey-Owen Sound Conservative Nay
Milliken, Peter (Hon) - Kingston and the Islands Liberal Speaker only votes in a tie
Mills, Bob - Red Deer Conservative Nay
Minna, Maria (Hon) - Beaches-East York Liberal Yea
Moore, James - Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam Conservative Nay
Moore, Rob - Fundy-Royal Conservative Nay
Mourani, Maria - Ahuntsic Bloc Quebecois Yea
Mulcair, Thomas - Outremont NDP Yea
Murphy, Brian - Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe Liberal Yea
Murphy, Shawn (Hon) - Charlottetown Liberal Yea
Nadeau, Richard - Gatineau Bloc Quebecois Yea
Nash, Peggy - Parkdale-High Park NDP Yea
Neville, Anita (Hon) - Winnipeg South Centre Liberal
Nicholson, Rob (Hon) - Niagara Falls Conservative Nay
Norlock, Rick - Northumberland-Quinte West Conservative Nay
Obhrai, Deepak - Calgary East Conservative Nay
O'Connor, Gordon (Hon) - Carleton-Mississippi Mills Conservative Nay
Oda, Bev (Hon) - Durham Conservative Nay
Ouellet, Christian - Brome-Missisquoi Bloc Quebecois Yea
Pacetti, Massimo - Saint-Leonard-Saint-Michel Liberal N/A* see note below
Pallister, Brian - Portage-Lisgar Conservative paired
Paquette, Pierre - Joliette Bloc Quebecois Yea
Paradis, Christian (Hon) - Megantic-L'Erable Conservative Nay
Patry, Bernard - Pierrefonds-Dollard Liberal Nay
Pearson, Glen - London North Centre Liberal Yea
Perron, Gilles-A. - Riviere-des-Mille-Iles Bloc Quebecois Yea
Petit, Daniel - Charlesbourg-Haute-Saint-Charles Conservative Nay
Picard, Pauline - Drummond Bloc Quebecois Yea
Plamandon, Louis - Bas-Richelieu-Nicolet-Becancour Bloc Quebecois Yea
Poilievre, Pierre - Nepean-Carleton Conservative Nay
Prentice, Jim (Hon) - Calgary Centre-North Conservative Nay
Preston, Joe - Elgin-Middlesex-London Conservative Nay
Priddy, Penny - Surrey North NDP Yea
Proulx, Marcel - Hull-Aylmer Liberal Nay
Rajotte, James - Edmonton-Leduc Conservative Nay
Ratansi, Yasmin - Don Valley East Liberal Nay
Redman, Karen (Hon) - Kitchener Centre Liberal Nay
Regan, Geoff (Hon) - Halifax West Liberal Yea
Reid, Scott - Lanark-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington Conservative Nay
Richardson, Lee - Calgary Centre Conservative Nay
Ritz, Gerry (Hon) - Battlefords-Lloydminster Conservative Nay
Robillard, Lucienne - Westmount-Ville-Marie Liberal
Rodriguez, Pablo - Honore-Mercier Liberal Yea
Rota, Anthony - Nipissing-Timiskaming Liberal Yea
Roy, Jean-Yves - Haute-Gaspesie-La Mitis-Matane-Matapedia Bloc Quebecois Yea
Russell, Todd - Labrador Liberal Nay
Savage, Michael - Dartmouth-Cole Harbour Liberal Nay
Savoie, Denise - Victoria NDP Yea
Scarpaleggia, Francis - Lac-Saint-Louis Liberal Nay
Scheer, Andrew - Regina-Qu'Appelle Conservative Nay
Schellenberger, Gary - Perth-Wellington Conservative Nay
Scott, Andy (Hon) - Fredericton Liberal Yea
Sgro, Judy (Hon) - York West Liberal Nay
Shipley, Bev - London-Kent-Middlesex Conservative Nay
Siksay, Bill - Burnaby-Douglas NDP Yea
Silva, Mario - Davenport Liberal Yea
Simard, Raymond (Hon) - St. Boniface Liberal Nay
Simms, Scott - Bonavista-Gander-Grand Falls-Windsor Liberal Yea
Skelton, Carol (Hon) - Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar Conservative Nay
Smith, Joy - Kildonan-St. Paul Conservative paired
Solberg, Monte (Hon) - Medicine Hat Conservative Nay
Sorenson, Kevin - Crowfoot Conservative Nay
St. Amand, Lloyd - Brant Liberal Yea
St. Denis, Brent - Algoma-Manitoulin-Kapuskasing Liberal Nay
Stanton, Bruce - Simcoe North Conservative Nay
St. Cyr, Thierry - Jeanne-Le Ber Bloc Quebecois Yea
Steckle, Paul - Huron Bruce Liberal Nay
St-Hilaire, Caroline - Longueuil-Pierre-Boucher Bloc Quebecois Yea
Stoffer, Peter - Sackville-Eastern Shore NDP Yea
Storseth, Brian - Westlock-St. Paul Conservative Nay
Strahl, Chuck (Hon) - Chilliwack-Fraser Canyon Conservative Nay
Stronach, Belinda (Hon) - Newmarket-Aurora Liberal
Sweet, David - Ancaster-Dundas-Flamborough-Westdale Conservative Nay
Szabo, Paul - Mississauga South Liberal Nay
Telegdi, Andrew (Hon) - Kitchener-Waterloo Liberal Yea
Temelkovski, Lui - Oak Ridges-Markham Liberal Nay
Thi Lac, Eve-Mary Thai - Saint-Hyancinthe-Bagot Bloc Quebecois Yea
Thibault, Louise - Rimouski-Neigette-Temiscouata-Les Basques Independent Yea
Thibault, Robert - West Nova Liberal Nay
Thompson, Greg Francis (Hon) - New Brunswick Southwest Conservative Nay
Thompson, Myron - Wild Rose Conservative Nay
Tilson, David - Dufferin-Caledon Conservative Nay
Toews, Vic (Hon) - Provencher Conservative Nay
Tonks, Alan - York South-Weston Liberal Yea
Trost, Bradley - Saskatoon-Humboldt Conservative Nay
Turner, Garth (Hon) - Halton Liberal Nay
Tweed, Mervin - Brandon-Souris Conservative Nay
Valley, Roger - Kenora Liberal Nay
Van Kesteren, Dave - Chatham-Kent-Essex Conservative Nay
Van Loan, Peter (Hon) - York-Simcoe Conservative Nay
Vellacott, Maurice - Saskatoon-Wanuskewin Conservative Nay
Verner, Josee (Hon) - Louis-Saint-Laurent Conservative Nay
Vincent, Robert - Shefford Bloc Quebecois Yea
Volpe, Joseph (Hon) - Elgin-Lawrence Liberal
Wallace, Mike - Burlington Conservative Nay
Wappel, Tom - Scarborough Southwest Liberal Yea
Warawa, Mark - Langley Conservative Nay
Warkentin, Chris - Peace River Conservative Nay
Wasylycia-Leis, Judy - Winnipeg North NDP Yea
Watson, Jeff - Essex Conservative Nay
Wilfert, Bryon (Hon) - Richmond Hill Liberal
Williams, John - Edmonton-St. Albert Conservative Nay
Wilson, Blair - West Vancouver-Sunshine Coast-Sea to Sky Country Independent Nay
Wrzesnewskyi, Borys - Etobicoke Centre Liberal Nay
Yelich, Lynne - Blackstrap Conservative Nay
Zed, Paul - St. John Liberal
  • Believe it or not, Massimo Pacetti is listed in the Hansard transcript as having voted both for and against this bill (April 8th, 2008). I have called his office and am awaiting confirmation on which way he voted. Check back soon and see which way this goes and (hopefully) whose name is missing from this list. We're just keeping them honest. - Paul
Unless stated otherwise Content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License